decision model · League 1

Winnow-12B

FinishedPublished

Results f24d1f41, updated 16 November 2026, 21:24 UTC; scored by GNU Backgammon 1.08, 2-ply.

How we called it

Model ID
winnow-12b
Provider or endpoint
NVIDIA RTX PRO 6000 Blackwell (96 GB), Q8_0 GGUF, author's server
Date run
2026-10-19 to 2026-10-26
Price
no price per token; estimate: GPU time, at most; source content/own_cost.json (wall clock on our machines × hourly rate); price date not recorded
Model type
decision model
Weights
open
Runs on
our GPUs
Reasoning setting
none (decision model)
Confidence source
decision-model probability
Rules text
long
Option groups
up to 40 options per request; more legal plays are split into equal groups, a winner per group, then among the winners; in this data 92 decisions were split into groups of 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40
Sampling settings
not sent (decision request)
Notes
a Gemma 4 12B IT fine-tune, run through its author's inference server with the author's configuration (Q8_0 GGUF); no published price

Results in League 1

Error rate (PR)
49.745.9 to 53.6
Decisions
2,015 (2,015 scored, 0 invalid)
Engine's best play
38.9%
Blunder rate
32.3%
P95 equity loss
0.456
Mean loss, worst 5%
0.688
Median / P90 s per decision
2.46 / 5.45
$ per 1,000 decisions
data-v="9.615">9.615estimate · RTX PRO 6000 Blackwell
Risk judgement, margin 0.001
55.2 (95% interval 52.9 to 57.2); risks found 33.7% (263 / 780), right safety 76.6% (573 / 748)
Risk judgement, margin 0.02
54.5 (95% interval 52.7 to 56.2); risks found 33.6% (233 / 693), right safety 75.3% (629 / 835)
No trade-off
487 (left out of every risk metric)

JSON

Risk call card

55.2risk judgement, margin 0.001

right risks263
wrong risks102
needless risks175
missed risks415
right safety573

Hit risk only: being hit. Gammon risk and priming are not in it.

Close choices

A decision is a close choice when the second most likely play has at least half the probability of the first (internally: split).

Probabilities over plays, not sampled reasoning. Method

Decisions
2,015
Eligible (full probability distribution)
1,705
Left out, by reason
asked in groups of options 81; not audited 229
Close choices
40.6% (692 / 1,705)
Ties in the top two
0 decisions (0 at a positive probability, 0 at 0; the two most likely plays tied: 0, the second tied with the third: 0); 0 of them close choices. Ties are broken by the order the plays were shown, never by the engine.
Between a safe play and a riskier one
35.1% (243 / 692) of the close choices; 14.3% (243 / 1,705) of all eligible decisions
Probabilities of the two most likely plays, mean with median
DecisionsNumberp1 (most likely play)p2 (second)p1 + p2
Close choices6920.395median 0.3880.291median 0.2860.686median 0.681
Other decisions1,0130.719median 0.7280.132median 0.1310.851median 0.885
How much probability the two plays hold together: decisions per bin
p1 + p20.0–0.10.1–0.20.2–0.30.3–0.40.4–0.50.5–0.60.6–0.70.7–0.80.8–0.90.9–1.0
Close choices003387412214211693104
Other decisions00011542100149250456
What differs between the two most likely plays (several can differ; none is picked as the cause)
DecisionsNumberHitting rollsNewly made pointsPip countsLongest primeNone / 1 / 2 / 3 / 4 differ
Close choices69250.6%350 / 69220.4%141 / 69213.6%94 / 69221.1%146 / 692227 / 276 / 124 / 53 / 12
Other decisions1,01356.7%574 / 1,01342.9%435 / 1,01310.4%105 / 1,01329.9%303 / 1,013188 / 380 / 313 / 117 / 15
Engine values (GNUbg 2-ply, equity), mean with median
DecisionsNumberGap between the two plays' valuesMost likely play: behind the engine's bestSecond most likely play: behind the engine's best
Close choices6920.126median 0.0590.111median 0.0290.119median 0.040
Other decisions1,0130.152median 0.0820.088median 0.0090.157median 0.077
Close choices between a safe play and a riskier one, by position class
MarginIn Risk pays positionsIn Safety pays positions
margin 0.00150.4%132 / 26247.0%111 / 236
margin 0.0248.9%109 / 22348.7%134 / 275
Close choices among eligible decisions, by position class and stake band
MarginRisk paysSafety paysNo trade-offRisk pays, small stakeRisk pays, medium stakeRisk pays, big stake
margin 0.00140.0%262 / 65538.1%236 / 62045.1%194 / 43053.4%39 / 73, under 200 decisions40.5%85 / 21037.1%138 / 372
margin 0.0238.3%223 / 58239.7%275 / 69345.1%194 / 430N/A0 / 040.5%85 / 21037.1%138 / 372

At the 0.02 margin a Risk pays position has a stake of at least 0.02, so the small band is empty. A big stake means playing safe costs more by the engine's value, not that the decision was harder.

Missed risks where the risk is worth taking, close choices vs other decisions
MarginClose choices: missed risksOther decisions: missed risks (weighted to the close choices' mix)Difference, close minus otherCrude difference
margin 0.001374 decisions62.0%crude 62.1% (82 / 132), under 200 decisions67.4%crude 66.9% (162 / 242)−5.4 points95% interval −15.4 to +5.6−4.8 points95% interval −14.8 to +5.4
margin 0.02330 decisions64.8%crude 65.1% (71 / 109), under 200 decisions65.2%crude 66.1% (146 / 221)−0.4 points95% interval −10.8 to +11.9−0.9 points95% interval −10.9 to +9.1

By game phase

PhaseError rate (PR)Decisions
Opening37.8298
Contact61.01,283
Holding gameToo few decisions67
Race20.2265
Bear-offToo few decisions102